Financial sharks circling Metro Bank

Image copyright Bill Cramer © Wonderful Machine Inc.
Image caption Metro Bank has paid £21m to Vernon Hill’s wife’s firm for its design work

Although Metro Bank recently came top of a consumer satisfaction league table, financial sharks are circling the challenger bank.

Metro Bank is now the second most shorted company on the UK stock market.

That means a lot of financial firms are betting the bank’s shares will continue to fall – despite having already lost 80% of their value in the last 12 months.


Recommended PRODUCTS
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • Specializing in telecommuting and work from home jobs.
  • With the help of this software, you can achieve financial freedom and live the life that you desire.
  • A simple system to plan and project your monthly expenses to keep yourself out of the red.
  • Define, refine and achieve your Goals with this powerful Goals program
  • Learn How To Earn Extra Money In Your Spare Time, By Watching Movies From Home
  • Bulletproof Home Ridiculous Hook Puts Insane In Your Bank Account
  • A Truly Unique Extract Of The Greatest Methodologies For Keeping The Body And Mind Young And Agile.
  • Discover how to boost your goal achieving skills in 30 days, guaranteed
  • Keep 100 Of The Profits By Selling Your Own Royalty Free Coaching Products
  • Discover How To Add 20lbs To Your Bench Press, 15lbs To Deadlift, And 20lbs To Your Squat In 3 Months
  • Discover A Unique Stock Trading Method That's Immune To Crashes And Financial Crises.
  • System unleashes the groundbreaking secrets of the latest demolisher betting system.
  • Take Action Today And Bank Up To 500 Every 30 Minutes Using My Secret Money Methods
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    Ever since Metro Bank revealed it had made an error in calculating how much shock absorbing capital it was holding, there have been some serious questions in the minds of regulators about the bank’s operating competence and in the minds of investors about its basic business model.

    So what’s been going on?

    Earlier this year the financial regulator, the PRA, raised concerns with the bank about inconsistencies in the reports it was submitting.

    It soon emerged that the bank had miscalculated the capital it needed to support some of its commercial lending. The news sent the banks shares down nearly 40% in one day as the bank said it would need to raise more capital by selling new shares.

    Miscalculating the amount of capital you have or need to support your lending is one of the most fundamental mistakes a bank can make.

    It gets to the very core of what a bank does – namely take deposits from savers and lend those out to borrowers.

    The bank’s capital is a financial cushion to make sure that depositors money is safe even if some of the borrowers can’t pay back their loans.

    One banking veteran told the BBC that it was “staggering, beggared belief” that a bank could get such a basic thing so wrong. “Operating with insufficient capital is the cardinal sin that brought us the financial crisis”.

    Metro Bank is clear that it had sufficient capital to support its current lending but analysts told the BBC that future growth plans also need to be supported as it planned to grow faster than it could earn additional money to support future lending.

    Capital calculations

    The amount of capital a bank needs is calculated by adding together three elements – or pillars – as they are known.

    Pillar one is the basic minimum capital calculation based on how much lending you have done and in which markets – the more you do, the riskier the types of loans – the more you need.

    Pillar two is the regulators assessment of bank specific risk. It’s a qualitative measure that looks at the bank’s size, maturity and operating history.

    Pillar three is the amount you need to support future growth.

    This is an important one for Metro which was trying to grow at 30% per year – which would require more additional capital than the bank could earn along the way.

    Well, those plans have changed. As Metro Bank licks its wounds after an embarrassing mistake, it has had to scale down its ambitions.

    It is now targeting growth of 20% rather than 30% – and that looks ambitious given the bank will be spending a considerable amount of money and management time dealing with two regulatory probes from the Financial Conduct Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority.

    So far – no heads have rolled as a result of the capital blunder. The chief executive Craig Donaldson offered to resign but the board did not accept it.

    Sources at the company told the BBC there was no appetite for “a witch hunt” but investors and regulators may need some blood on the carpet to satisfy them.

    If the chief executive stays, the focus then shifts to the board and here is another area where investors are concerned that Metro Bank is falling short of the standards required of a bank.

    Sense of fun

    The chairman and founder Vernon Hill is an engaging and charismatic figure whose mould breaking approach to banking was seen by many as a breath of fresh air.

    I was present at the launch of the first UK Metro Bank in Holborn, London nearly 10 years ago. There was razzmatazz, balloons, bands, Saturday, Sunday and Bank holiday opening hours and dog bowls and biscuits – thanks to the influence of Vernon Hill’s wife Shirley and her ever present companion Duffy the Yorkshire Terrier.

    So what? Just what the High Street needs – a bank that’s open when you want it to be with a sense of fun about it.

    Customers liked it. What investors were unsure about was the £21m Metro Bank paid to Shirley Hill’s company InterArch for its design work.

    Royal London Asset Management and Glass Lewis – a firm that advises shareholders how to vote – both described the relationship as “inappropriate” and voted against Vernon Hill’s re-election as chairman. They were convincingly outvoted.

    Many of the board have been there a long time – a practice that is increasingly frowned upon as it can foster cosy relationships between the board and the management – leading to insufficient challenge and scrutiny.

    Six of its nine non-executive directors have been on the board almost since day one – nine years ago – coincidentally the maximum recommended term for a director under the company governance code.

    Even if, as seems likely, there is a boardroom clear out, doubts still remain in the minds of some about the underlying business model.

    Image caption Metro Bank chair Vernon Hill with dog Duffy

    After all, Metro Bank is trying to do the exact opposite of what many other banks are doing.

    It is growing its network of branches while others are shrinking theirs. It is opening in the most expensive locations in the towns and cities it operates in. Its branches are open Saturdays, Sundays and Bank Holidays.

    Sometimes doing something counter-intuitive or a bit different is good. Sometimes there is a reason that no-one else is doing it. For many investors, it’s a case of the latter.

    A gamble

    One former shareholder said there were two important reasons why. First, this Metro Bank model “will only ever appeal to a subset of customers – it is never going to be the same scale as even a TSB let alone a Lloyds and that matters because you can’t get the cost as percentage of your revenue down without scale.

    It will always be a more expensive business and therefore lower returning business to own”.

    Second, the rate of growth they are targeting means that for the next few years you are paying to own this company rather than being paid.

    The bank will continue to need more capital put in by shareholders and that is a gamble for a niche bank that is expensive to run.

    The chief executive Craig Donaldson insists that comparisons with the rest of the industry tell a misleading story.

    “You have to remember that RBS is coming down from over 2,000 branches, we are heading up from the current 66 to a target of 200. That is the size of business we are targeting.”

    As mentioned already, Metro Bank has proved popular with customers and has shown impressive growth with minimal advertising. To be clear there is no suggestion that customer deposits are at any risk.

    But the model is not winning the popularity contest with investors – its shares have fallen nearly 80% and some heavyweight financial gamblers are betting heavily on it falling further.

    In the final analysis, no amount of razzmatazz and dog biscuits can take investors eyes off the financial ball and right now it is a long way from being in the back of the net.

    One to watch.

    Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

     


    RELATED PRODUCTS
  • Specializing in telecommuting and work from home jobs.
  • A simple system to plan and project your monthly expenses to keep yourself out of the red.
  • With the help of this software, you can achieve financial freedom and live the life that you desire.
  • Are you frustrated that your expensive karoke player does not let you play.
  • A Truly Unique Extract Of The Greatest Methodologies For Keeping The Body And Mind Young And Agile.
  • Caretaker-Jobs.com is dedicated to serving the needs of property owners and caretakers world wide.
  • The stunning secret of turning your wife on with the push of a button.
  • Helps You To Lose Weight In Just Four Weeks Without Strict Dieting And Exercise.
  • The Source Code For Success will make abundance simple and fast for you
  • Learn How To Attract the Man of Your Dreams And Receive A Marriage Proposal In Few Months
  • Watch this video and GET READY for the next financial collapse, your family may depend on it.
  • Packed full of the info you need for profitable horse racing
  • Learn how to make wonderful smelling candles that put expensive candles sold in stores.
  • Reveals 1 Unusual Tip To Eliminate Excessive Sweating Forever In 48 Hours
  • Clickbank Ads
     

    Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

    If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

    And ... Don't forget to have fun!

    Recommended

    Trafficzing Basic

    Turn Any Image into Clicks

    Handy Wood Kit

    Handy Wood Kit is a wood-themed hand gesture video kit designed to work with Easy Video Lab and Easy Video Lab Lite. Handy Wood Kit can be used to create hand gesture videos. Handy Wood Kit also comes with free software, Easy Video Lab Lite

    Leave a Reply